Factors limiting the utility of bronchoalveolar lavage in the diagnosis of Covid-19
Image : https://cdn0-production-images-kly.akamaized.net/oi4dKUUx5LlqjfDIDCamByxB5cs=/640x360/smart/filters:quality(75):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/kly-media-production/medias/3097828/original/096061400_1586403973-concept-of-covid-19-in-red-background-4031867.j
DeepakÂ Aggarwal,Â VarinderÂ Saini
European Respiratory JournalÂ 2020;Â DOI:Â 10.1183/13993003.03116-2020
Bronchoalveolar lavage has a specific place in the diagnosis of Covid-19. The clinical performance of BAL rRt-PCR is dynamic in nature and depends on different clinical and demographic factors.
We read with interest study by GeriÂ et al.Â in which the authors have demonstrated a strong agreement between negative nasopharyngeal (NPs)/nasal (Ns) swab and bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) real-time reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (rRT-PCR) in the diagnosis of Covid-19 among hospitalised patients. The study findings contradicted earlier report and suggested a limited utility of BAL. However, the results need to be interpreted comprehensively before drawing any conclusion.
In the present study, BAL was negative for SARS-CoV-2 by rRT-PCR in majority of cases that included 38 patients (48%) with strong clinical and radiological suspicion for Covid-19. This finding implies either a high false negative rate of BAL rRT-PCR or an alternate diagnosis. Hence, authors should give a detail account of the final diagnoses and treatment outcomes of the patients and correlate these with the rRT-PCR results. This will give a better picture of the clinical performance of rRT-PCR in both BAL and upper respiratory samples.
Clinical test performance of rRT-PCR (in BAL/Ns/NPs) is a dynamic parameter that depends not only on its analytic sensitivity but also on the pretest probability. The pretest probability may in turn depend on the SARS-CoV-2 exposure history, disease symptoms and local disease prevalence. The unexpected low positivity seen with BAL rRT-PCR in the study despite high pretest probability might be due to delayed time of sampling and/or disease stage. All these factors should have been considered while comparing the diagnostic yield in the study
Bronchoalveolar lavage has a specific place in the diagnostic algorithm of Covid-19 and is usually performed in a patient with lower respiratory tract involvement and high clinical suspicion but negative Ns/NPs result. However, negative BAL results should be interpreted comprehensively in light of different clinical and demographic factors on a case-to-case basis.
Conflict of interest: Dr. AGGARWAL has nothing to disclose.
Conflict of interest: Dr. SAINI has nothing to disclose.
- ReceivedÂ August 12, 2020.
- AcceptedÂ August 20, 2020.
- Copyright Â©ERS 2020
, Dr Koentjahja, SpP
Nusakambangan 56, Malang 65117
08113777488 / 362017 ext. 88.23
Pukul 18.00 - 20.00, kec. Sabtu, Minggu / Libur
tgl 1-5 feb libur, buka tgl 6 feb